Case 1 – Alkali-Silica Reaction

Navigation

Good Practices

  • Using low-alkali cement reduces the amount of alkalis available for the reaction.
  • Selecting non-reactive aggregates or using supplementary cementitious materials (such as fly ash or silica fume) can also mitigate ASR.
  • Proper concrete mix design and curing practices help reduce the risk of ASR.
  • Monitoring and maintenance, including sealing cracks and controlling moisture ingress, can help manage existing ASR-related issues.

Concrete

Design

An understanding of the environment /atmospheric conditions should be taken into consideration during the design stage.

EnvironmentExposure conditions
MildConcrete surfaces protected against weather or aggressive conditions
ModerateExposed concrete surfaces but sheltered from severe rain or severe traffic

 

Concrete surfaces continuously under non-aggressive water

Concrete in contact with non aggressive soil


Concrete subject to condensation

SevereConcrete surfaces exposed to severe rain, alternate wetting and drying or occasional freezing or severe condensation

 

Concrete surfaces occasionally exposed to light traffic

Very severeConcrete surfaces occasionally exposed to seawater spray (directly or indirectly)
Concrete surfaces exposed to corrosive fumes and heavy traffic
Most severeConcrete surfaces frequently exposed to seawater spray (directly or indirectly) and heavy traffic
AbrasiveConcrete surfaces exposed to abrasive action.

Table 1: Classification of exposure conditions [2]

Material

Since this defect arises from the presence of alkali-silica reactive aggregates, it would be a good practice to minimize the alkali content in the concrete and use non-reactive aggregates.

Measures that can be taken include:

  • reduce the degree of saturation of the concrete such as impermeable membranes
  • use of any low alkali (less than 0.6% equivalent sodium oxide content) Portland cement; such a cement is available under BS 4027 (Withdrawn) [3]
  • limit the alkali content of the concrete mix to 3kg/m3 of equivalent sodium oxide content.
  • admixtures that would either preferentially replace the alkalis or immobilize them are used.

Cement should comply with SS EN 197 series while coarse and fine aggregates used should comply with SS EN 12620. All aggregates shall be stored in clean places [6]. Table 2 shows the various concrete grades to be achieved.

Concrete Grade3035404550
Minimum cement content (kg per m3)275300325350400
Maximum cement content (kg per m3)550550550550550
Maximum % of Fine Aggregate to Total Aggregate5050505050
Maximum water to cement ratio0.550.500.450.400.40

Table 2: Designed mix of concrete [3]

Construction

  • Ready mix concrete is preferred over site mixed concrete to achieve consistency.
  • Check for quality of concrete before placing [4]. e.g. water cement ratio, slump test, etc.
  • Place the concrete carefully. If concrete is placed directly from a truck or concrete pump, place concrete vertically into position. Do not allow the concrete to fall more than 1 to 1.5 meters.
  • Ensure thorough compaction of the concrete during placement.

Quality control

Avoid following during concreting to minimize cracks:

  • Avoid excessive manipulation of the surface, which can depress the coarse aggregate, increase the cement paste at the surface, or increase the water-cement ratio at the surface.
  • DO NOT finish the concrete before it has completed bleeding.
  • Do not dust any cement onto the surface to absorb bleed water.
  • Do not sprinkle water on the surface while finishing.

The admissible concrete and steel stresses in the façade elements should not exceed the following indicative stresses. Admissible concrete and steel stress:

  • During demoulding: 10 to 15 N/mm2
  • In service: 45 N/mm2 or 0.67 fc/m whichever is the lesser.
  • Admissible steel stresses: In order to decrease the risk of cracking, the stress of the main reinforcement near to the visual faces of the elements will be limited to maximum 120 N/mm2.
  • It is recommended to use steel with deformed profile giving improved adhesion, and the diameters smaller or equal to 16mm.

Reinforcement

Design

Sufficient concrete cover should be provided to prevent corrosion of reinforcement.

Condition of exposureNominal cover    
Mild2520202020
Moderate35302520
Severe403025
Very severe504030
Most severe50
Abrasivesee note 3see note 3
Maximum free water/cement ratio0.650.600.550.50.45
Minimum cement content (kg/m3)275300325350400
Lowest grade of concreteC30C35C40C45C50
1) This table relates to normal-weight aggregate of 20mm nominal size. Adjustments to minimum cement contents for aggregates other than 20 mm nominal maximum size are detailed in BS EN 206+A2.

Table 3: Limiting values of the nominal cover of normal weight aggregate concrete [2]

Material

All high yield reinforcement bars should comply with SS 2 and welded steel fabric should comply with SS 32 [3]. Reinforcement can be protected further by using following methods:

  • removal of rust and mill scale before embedment
  • use of non-metallic coatings such as epoxy resins and solvent containing acrylic resins[5]
  • use of metallic coatings such as zinc and nickel
  • Cathodic protection
  • use of corrosion inhibitors
  • use of corrosion resistance reinforcement (e.g. stainless steel)
  • use of low permeability concrete, with improved resistance to chloride ion ingress

Surface coating

Alkali silicate-based mineral masonry coatings may be used. They are based on an alkali silicate solution (usually sodium or potassium silicate) in water and are pigmented with alkali-resistant pigments [9].

Alkali silicate-based masonry coatings may be modified by additions of aqueous polymer dispersions, such as acrylic copolymer having good resistance to alkali to modify their drying characteristics under adverse conditions and other physical properties [9].